Director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson explains why the duo’s scene—originally planned as the film’s opening—was ultimately left on the cutting room floor.

The I Know What You Did Last Summer reboot sequel boasts a fresh ensemble cast, including rising stars Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Sarah Pidgeon, Tariq Weathers, and Jonah Hauer-King. However, fans won’t see two previously announced actors, Lola Tung and Nicholas Alexander Chavez, in the final version—and Robinson has opened up about why.
In an exclusive interview with People, Robinson revealed that Tung and Chavez filmed what was meant to be the movie’s opening sequence. But during editing, she realized the scene, while strong on its own, didn’t mesh with the rest of the film.
“Every filmmaker goes in with a vision, but sometimes in the editing room, you have to make tough calls,” Robinson explained. “I loved their scene in isolation—it was fantastic. But when you see the bigger picture, it just didn’t fit the flow of the story.”
She was quick to praise the actors, emphasizing that the decision had nothing to do with their performances. “Lola and Nicholas were incredible—total professionals. I’d jump at the chance to work with them again,” she said. “But in the grand scheme of the film, this particular moment didn’t serve the narrative.”
Robinson admitted cutting the scene was a difficult choice. “It’s never easy telling actors their work won’t make the final cut, especially when they did such a great job,” she added. “Sometimes you fall in love with a scene, but if it doesn’t elevate the movie as a whole, you have to let it go.”
At the film’s Los Angeles premiere, Robinson told Variety that both actors took the news graciously. “They were so understanding and professional about it,” she said, before hinting, “Who knows? Maybe we’ll see them in a sequel.”
This new installment serves as a follow-up to both the 1997 original and its 1998 sequel, I Still Know What You Did Last Summer. The story follows a new group of friends (played by Cline, Wonders, Pidgeon, Weathers, and Hauer-King) as they confront a dark secret from their past.
Franchise veterans Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt reprise their iconic roles, but one key star from the original—Sarah Michelle Gellar—won’t be returning, despite Robinson’s best efforts.
“I tried everything—even pitched some wild ideas to bring her back,” Robinson admitted to Entertainment Weekly. “I said, ‘What if you faked your death and were hiding all this time?’ But Sarah joked, ‘Nope, I was frozen solid on-screen. I’m dead dead.’”
Fans can catch I Know What You Did Last Summer in theaters on July 18, 2025.

















