The Sex and the City star just dropped a long-awaited truth bomb about her past relationship with a famous co-star—and no, it’s not who you might expect.

During a candid chat on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, Parker opened up about her love life, starting with the moment she knew her now-husband, Matthew Broderick, was “the one.”

“I remember getting into a car on East 10th Street, heading off to film a movie, and suddenly it hit me—I was in love with him,” she shared. “I just knew he was special from the start.”

Parker admitted she was the one who said “I love you” first, telling Cohen, “I figured I had nothing to lose.”

But just when things were getting sentimental, Cohen switched gears with a spicy question: “Did you date Nicolas Cage?”

After a brief pause, Parker confirmed the long-standing rumor: “Um, yes, I did.”

“Oh wow,” Cohen replied, clearly thrilled by the revelation. “We’ve got some catching up to do.”

The two starred together in the 1991 rom-com Honeymoon in Vegas, sparking dating rumors—though their romance was short-lived. By the next year, Parker was spotted with Broderick, and the couple tied the knot in 1997.

As for Cage? He’s been married five times since then.

Looks like this Hollywood mystery is finally solved!